[Final vote] The Deskthority

The Deskthority

Poll ended at 10 Dec 2016, 20:00

The Model MF team for the Model MF kit
87
28%
Daniel Beardsmore for Deskthority Wiki work
62
20%
Chyros for his videos and majestic voice
36
12%
XMIT for bringing back Hall Effect
43
14%
Ripster55 for spreading his knowledge on reddit
79
26%
 
Total votes : 307
And what better thread for new members to have a taste of the tangents that await them.. :twisted:
emdude
User avatar
Model M Apologist

Unread post08 Dec 2016, 02:32

User avatar
X
emdude
Model M Apologist
 
Posts: 948
Joined: 23 Jan 2016, 06:53
Location: California, US
Main keyboard: IBM Model M SSK // Unicomp Ultra Classic 103
Main mouse: Logitech M510
Favorite switch: Beam Spring // Buckling Spring
Club member: 0160
 
emdude wrote:And what better thread for new members to have a taste of the tangents that await them.. :twisted:

Seriously, be ready for things to go in ANY direction...

Which is why I enjoy this place.
vivalarevolución
User avatar
formerly prdlm2009

Unread post08 Dec 2016, 03:09

User avatar
X
vivalarevolución
formerly prdlm2009
 
Posts: 1827
Joined: 14 Sep 2012, 19:09
Location: USA
Main keyboard: IBM Beam spring
Main mouse: Kangaroo
Favorite switch: beam spring
Club member: 0097
 
I'm sure no one will remember this for next year, but if we don't have ranked choice voting, we could do the next best thing. Make it a rule that the winner has to have a majority of votes. If no one has a majority after one round of final voting, hold a runoff vote between the top two vote getters.
Techno Trousers
User avatar
100,000,000 actuations

Unread post08 Dec 2016, 03:11

User avatar
X
Techno Trousers
100,000,000 actuations
 
Posts: 745
Joined: 14 Jun 2013, 01:16
Location: California
Main keyboard: IBM Model F-122
Main mouse: Mionix Naos
Favorite switch: Capacitive Buckling Spring (Model F)
Club member: 0159
 
Techno Trousers wrote:I'm sure no one will remember this for next year, but if we don't have ranked choice voting, we could do the next best thing. Make it a rule that the winner has to have a majority of votes. If no one has a majority after one round of final voting, hold a runoff vote between the top two vote getters.

I think we should take Wodan's advice and move this type of discussion to the Club business subforum.
vivalarevolución
User avatar
formerly prdlm2009

Unread post08 Dec 2016, 03:49

User avatar
X
vivalarevolución
formerly prdlm2009
 
Posts: 1827
Joined: 14 Sep 2012, 19:09
Location: USA
Main keyboard: IBM Beam spring
Main mouse: Kangaroo
Favorite switch: beam spring
Club member: 0097
 
Techno Trousers wrote:I'm sure no one will remember this for next year, but if we don't have ranked choice voting, we could do the next best thing. Make it a rule that the winner has to have a majority of votes. If no one has a majority after one round of final voting, hold a runoff vote between the top two vote getters.

How will it be a best thing? Why does the winner has to have a quota of votes? What bother you in the fact that the one with most votes wins? Ranked choice voting is enforcement of social engineering of masses, it reminds me of these words from Lo Stato Sociale song "Nella guerra per la pace vince da sempre il voto moderato" (In the war for peace always wins the moderate vote), plus in the awards we are voting for, it is by far less fun.
And now you want to reduce our choices even more, gee…
mecano
User avatar

Unread post08 Dec 2016, 14:55

User avatar
X
mecano
 
Posts: 322
Joined: 16 Dec 2014, 21:01
Location: Paris
Main keyboard: Tipro KMX128
Main mouse: Kensington Orbit Trackball with scroll ring
Favorite switch: Beam Spring
 
mecano wrote:
What bother you in the fact that the one with most votes wins?


"most votes wins" is acceptable if the field is very small (eg <3-4) but in a more fragmented field then a random outlier can subvert the will of the majority if that has become splintered between similar choices.
fohat
User avatar

Unread post08 Dec 2016, 21:35

User avatar
X
fohat
 
Posts: 2064
Joined: 07 Oct 2011, 02:09
Location: Atlanta, Georgia
Main keyboard: Model F 122-key terminal
Main mouse: Microsoft Optical Mouse
Favorite switch: Model F Buckling Spring
Club member: 0158
 
A ranked voting system is clearly the answer here.
XMIT
User avatar
[ XMIT ]

Unread post08 Dec 2016, 22:01

User avatar
X
XMIT
[ XMIT ]
 
Posts: 3199
Joined: 21 Dec 2014, 15:32
Location: Austin, TX, USA
Main keyboard: XMIT Hall Effect
Main mouse: Logitech Marble Mouse
Favorite switch: XMIT 50g Hall Effect
Club member: 0093
 
Why do we need anything more than a simple one vote, relative majority winner system? We already have 2 rounds of voting, and the point is to vote for our one favourite X. What advantage would a ranked or other system present to make it worth the complications? I'd rather see a nominee I didn't vote for win than seeing most voters' second choice win.
chzel
User avatar

Unread post08 Dec 2016, 22:37

User avatar
X
chzel
 
Posts: 2338
Joined: 25 May 2014, 17:51
Location: Athens, Greece
Main keyboard: Phantom
Main mouse: Mionix Avior 7000
Favorite switch: Beamspring, BS, Vintage Blacks.
Club member: 0086
 
I know I should keep my #$%!ing mouth shut here (a smarter or at least greedier person would), but I would prefer we just kept the voting simple. Before you vote, actually LOOK at the body of work for EVERYTHING, it's merit, it's impact... and vote based on what YOU feel is the MOST deserving (not ranked, no agendas, but your favorite contribution). I asked about the scope of this, because I was confused as to whether this is 2016 only or lifetime award... and learned that is your decision as a voter.

There is no question that everything that made it this far is fantastic (it's been an AWESOME year). Turning this into some forum warfare with an agenda feels tainted/gross, and that isn't what this is about. Whomever this is awarded to should feel pride about what happened here, what they or their team accomplished, and see the wingnut for what it is.... special. I would hope that any of the nominees would rather lose with pride than win with forum motives and "vote for me" stickies. Otherwise we should all make a pact right now to paint the damn thing black once awarded. I think we are bigger than that.

Let's clean it up, and worry about voting system changes for next year if we need to (this is what we have for now). If you are voting for our (MF) team, but really wanted something else... it's on you to change your vote back if you prefer. Sorry in advance to the other members of my group that aren't being consulted about this little rant ahead of time :), but I know the type of people you are, and I know you would feel the same.
lot_lizard
User avatar

Unread post08 Dec 2016, 22:39

User avatar
X
lot_lizard
 
Posts: 1326
Joined: 20 Feb 2016, 03:36
Location: Minnesota
Main keyboard: Indy SSK Model MF
Main mouse: Logitech Anywhere MX
Favorite switch: Beamspring
Club member: 0153
 
lot_lizard wrote:
I asked about the scope of this, because I was confused as to whether this is 2016 only or lifetime award ....


Yes, I agree that this needs to be clarified.

My understanding was that this was/is the "2016 Deskthority Awards" which means, to me:

Awards, from and by Deskthority, for persons and things accomplished during the year 2016.

Who is eligible to vote, and to win, these awards may be open to interpretation, but what the awards themselves represent should be defined unambiguously.
fohat
User avatar

Unread post08 Dec 2016, 23:32

User avatar
X
fohat
 
Posts: 2064
Joined: 07 Oct 2011, 02:09
Location: Atlanta, Georgia
Main keyboard: Model F 122-key terminal
Main mouse: Microsoft Optical Mouse
Favorite switch: Model F Buckling Spring
Club member: 0158
 
I think it's actually very clear:
webwit wrote:Nomination rules:
Use this topic to suggest nominees for The Deskthority 2016. This is the main award and "super category," so anything goes. You can suggest a keyboard, company, keycap set, person, etc. It can be something or someone already nominated in another category as well. In fact, please post strong candidates from other categories. What has been extra special since Thursday 3 December, 2015? Who earns the Golden Wingnut? You have to give a short motivation for each suggestion. You cannot nominate yourself.

(bold and underlining added for emphasis)

This award is for someone's contribution/influence/whatever since the last DTA.
chzel
User avatar

Unread post08 Dec 2016, 23:42

User avatar
X
chzel
 
Posts: 2338
Joined: 25 May 2014, 17:51
Location: Athens, Greece
Main keyboard: Phantom
Main mouse: Mionix Avior 7000
Favorite switch: Beamspring, BS, Vintage Blacks.
Club member: 0086
 
Ripster was nominated "for continuing to spread his knowledge on reddit and general shitposting" in 2016, and the nomination is therefore allowed.

I can only speculate about voter motivations. It's ok if they take into account a "lifetime" of work, it's also ok to dismiss that and concentrate on this year only, this Award is pretty open, the voters will decide who deserves this year's golden Wingnut.

It's not like they lack opinion. :twisted:

Haven't you voted yet? Please vote for your favorite:

  • The Model MF team for the Model MF kit
  • Daniel Beardsmore for Deskthority Wiki work
  • Chyros for his videos and majestic voice
  • XMIT for bringing back Hall Effect
  • Ripster55 for spreading his knowledge on reddit
webwit
User avatar
Wild Duck

Unread post08 Dec 2016, 23:49

User avatar
X
webwit
Wild Duck
 
Posts: 9722
Joined: 27 Jan 2011, 23:27
Location: The Netherlands
Main keyboard: HHKB Pro II
Favorite switch: IBM beam spring
Club member: 0000
 
lot_lizard wrote:I know I should keep my #$%!ing mouth shut here (a smarter or at least greedier person would), but I would prefer we just kept the voting simple. Before you vote, actually LOOK at the body of work for EVERYTHING, it's merit, it's impact... and vote based on what YOU feel is the MOST deserving (not ranked, no agendas, but your favorite contribution). I asked about the scope of this, because I was confused as to whether this is 2016 only or lifetime award... and learned that is your decision as a voter.

There is no question that everything that made it this far is fantastic (it's been an AWESOME year). Turning this into some forum warfare with an agenda feels tainted/gross, and that isn't what this is about. Whomever this is awarded to should feel pride about what happened here, what they or their team accomplished, and see the wingnut for what it is.... special. I would hope that any of the nominees would rather lose with pride than win with forum motives and "vote for me" stickies. Otherwise we should all make a pact right now to paint the damn thing black once awarded. I think we are bigger than that.

Let's clean it up, and worry about voting system changes for next year if we need to (this is what we have for now). If you are voting for our (MF) team, but really wanted something else... it's on you to change your vote back if you prefer. Sorry in advance to the other members of my group that aren't being consulted about this little rant ahead of time :), but I know the type of people you are, and I know you would feel the same.

Free speech forum, no need to feel that you need to keep your mouth shut!

Whatever happens, happens. It's a frickin keyboard forum awards ceremony, let's not take it too seriously. Regardless, the award has brought some attention to some seriously awesome projects, even if the winner ends up not being the person/team that we voted for.

The Deskthority Awards are one of a kind, a wonderful annual event. A little tiff here and there does not change that.
vivalarevolución
User avatar
formerly prdlm2009

Unread post09 Dec 2016, 01:56

User avatar
X
vivalarevolución
formerly prdlm2009
 
Posts: 1827
Joined: 14 Sep 2012, 19:09
Location: USA
Main keyboard: IBM Beam spring
Main mouse: Kangaroo
Favorite switch: beam spring
Club member: 0097
 
lot_lizard wrote:[…] If you are voting for our (MF) team, but really wanted something else... it's on you to change your vote back if you prefer. […]

Let me explain with full details why, after first having chosen another nominee, I am now voting for the model MF team.

- My vote first went to Daniel Beardsmore because of his fantastic work on the wiki, with hundreds and hundreds of contributions since he even stopped posting in the forum more than 18 months ago. I think he can't be praised enough for that.
- My second choice would have been Chyros for his videos (simply for his videos, since I'm not that much into even that impressive male voices :lol: )
- The reason why I had first considered neither the Model MF team nor XMIT in this category is simple: I am not interested in IBM stuff, know nothing about it and only randomly follow what's happening in this portion of the keyboard universe.
- And I considered ripster as a silly joke, as only very few still know him on DT and those who do probably wouldn't vote for him.

My assumption ripster had no chance was proven wrong when the two top contenders were announced.

Still considering ripster as a silly joke, I decided to change my vote because this (and making it public, i.e. encouraging others to do the same), appears to be the only way I can prevent DT from ridiculously giving a trophy bearing its name to someone who was banned from DT for good reasons (restless trolling and literally flooding the forum with spam so that he had to be put on a 1 post/hour limit and then restarted spamming as soon as the limit was lifted).
kbdfr
User avatar
The Tiproman

Unread post09 Dec 2016, 06:25

User avatar
X
kbdfr
The Tiproman
 
Posts: 4371
Joined: 24 Mar 2011, 13:06
Location: Berlin, Germany
Main keyboard: Tipro MID-QM-128A + two Tipro matrix modules
Main mouse: Contour Rollermouse Pro
Favorite switch: Cherry black
Club member: 0010
 
XMIT for sure.
Shihatsu

Unread post09 Dec 2016, 08:59

X
Shihatsu
 
Posts: 93
Joined: 24 Jan 2016, 10:40
Location: Germany
Main keyboard: WASD V2 TKL
Main mouse: Roccat Kone Optical Black
Favorite switch: Cherry MX Green
Club member: 0170
 
I'm glad Tom Wong/xwhatis won :) Cheers to the whole crew too!
mecano
User avatar

Unread post14 Dec 2016, 15:24

User avatar
X
mecano
 
Posts: 322
Joined: 16 Dec 2014, 21:01
Location: Paris
Main keyboard: Tipro KMX128
Main mouse: Kensington Orbit Trackball with scroll ring
Favorite switch: Beam Spring
 
mecano wrote:I'm glad Tom Wong/xwhatis won :) Cheers to the whole crew too!
Couldn't agree more... will work hard to find all of these yahoos and make sure the "nut" spends as much time as they like with each. Such a fun year, and one I will remember forever. We have so much talent and passion as a community. Makes me proud to see that we can rally that behind a mission!!! Normally "gifted" nerds are either in two facets:
  • those that need to prove that they shouldn't have been picked on in school
  • those that help EVERYONE in an unbridled way
I think DT is the latter. Community of free thinkers, not afraid to speak their mind, though able adapt to each other. It's a rare group to find I think, and glad I joined it.
lot_lizard
User avatar

Unread post14 Dec 2016, 19:24

User avatar
X
lot_lizard
 
Posts: 1326
Joined: 20 Feb 2016, 03:36
Location: Minnesota
Main keyboard: Indy SSK Model MF
Main mouse: Logitech Anywhere MX
Favorite switch: Beamspring
Club member: 0153
 
Previous

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests