Future of mechanical switches? which one is the best?

just_add_coffee wrote:The future of ALL switches is zilch. Nada. Nothing. The near-future is voice, and the not-too-distant-future is thought. But in the here-and-now, the best mechanical switch is old school IBM buckling spring, though if you like artisan keysets, keycaps, customization, color, etc., you should give the newest Kailh offerings a look.

I don't think the near-future is voice, because many of us now work in open-plan offices or, at the very least, have to share our offices with a few other people. Nobody'd be able to focus if they'd have to listen to their colleagues all day, and the computer would likely start picking up some of the background noise as well.

Wearing headphones to block the sound of others talking could get tiring after a while, and would also cut you off from ordinary chit-chat.

Having the computer type your thoughts isn't such a good idea, either, as people tend to loose focus after a while - the computer would start putting out gibberish at that stage.
Cattus_D

Unread post06 Feb 2018, 19:50

X
Cattus_D
 
Posts: 81
Joined: 28 Sep 2016, 22:13
Location: Netherlands
Main keyboard: IBM Model M
Main mouse: IBM MO18B
Favorite switch: Model M buckling spring
DT Pro Member: -
 
Cattus_D wrote:
just_add_coffee wrote:The future of ALL switches is zilch. Nada. Nothing. The near-future is voice, and the not-too-distant-future is thought. But in the here-and-now, the best mechanical switch is old school IBM buckling spring, though if you like artisan keysets, keycaps, customization, color, etc., you should give the newest Kailh offerings a look.

I don't think the near-future is voice, because many of us now work in open-plan offices or, at the very least, have to share our offices with a few other people. Nobody'd be able to focus if they'd have to listen to their colleagues all day, and the computer would likely start picking up some of the background noise as well. Plus doing a lot of talking may put too much strain on the voice.

Wearing headphones to block the sound of others talking could get tiring after a while, and would also cut you off from ordinary chit-chat.

Having the computer type your thoughts isn't such a good idea, either, as people tend to lose focus after a while - the computer would start putting out gibberish at that stage.
Cattus_D

Unread post06 Feb 2018, 19:51

X
Cattus_D
 
Posts: 81
Joined: 28 Sep 2016, 22:13
Location: Netherlands
Main keyboard: IBM Model M
Main mouse: IBM MO18B
Favorite switch: Model M buckling spring
DT Pro Member: -
 
it's hard to say what the future will bring i don't have a "crystal ball".

I can however share with you what i would consider worthwhile improvements that go beyond my switch preference as i don't know what the future will bring that preference could change and i believe in keeping an open mind.

Last week i finally decided to mod my Topre FC660C with hypersphere rings i got two years ago from a great GB here on DT. i also lubed them with SuperLube Oil and SuperLube grease.

Oh man what a difference and improvement finally i understand what the fuss is all about with Topre Smoothness and silence.. or more accurate nice low topre Tok...

thinking of the results i achieved without the need to de-solder and re-solder my board.
i would say / hope that the future would bring something i saw with the K-type keyboard nice easy switch replacement modding without the need to solder / de-solder that is something everyone should want.. The idea that i need to desolder a board to fix a stabilizer that is misbehaving sounds awful to me now that i modded / improved my first keyboard..

So in short the best switch is the one that gives the most freedom to mod with the least effort (low-bar)..
TuxKey
User avatar
LLAP

Unread post06 Feb 2018, 20:48

User avatar
X
TuxKey
LLAP
 
Posts: 436
Joined: 04 Jun 2014, 19:59
Location: Netherlands
Main keyboard: Leopold FC660C, Leopold FC660M mx-clears
Main mouse: Apple Magic Trackpad, ducky Secret (PBT mouse)
Favorite switch: Cherry MX-clear, Topre 45gr/55gr
DT Pro Member: 0137
 
FXT wrote:You owe it to your fingers to try a Model F. As for lifespan, the F is rated for 100,000,000 keypresses which is more than plenty imo.

Thats why I need one :lol: Model M? Its for plebs! (using it now its good), Beamspring? Too big! Model F? Perfect.
Getting one in Slovenia is quite tricky tho :P
Dingster
User avatar

Unread post06 Feb 2018, 21:08

User avatar
X
Dingster
 
Posts: 372
Joined: 07 Jan 2018, 13:51
Location: Slovenia
Main keyboard: Model M/G80-1800/MF68
Main mouse: Logitech M500
Favorite switch: Good linears
DT Pro Member: -
 
Dingster wrote:
FXT wrote:You owe it to your fingers to try a Model F. As for lifespan, the F is rated for 100,000,000 keypresses which is more than plenty imo.

Thats why I need one :lol: Model M? Its for plebs! (using it now its good), Beamspring? Too big! Model F? Perfect.
Getting one in Slovenia is quite tricky tho :P

I personally wouldn't even say that beamsprings are better than capacitive buckling springs. I love my DisplayWriter, but they're two different switches. Definitely agree, for daily use the F is unbeatable.
FXT
User avatar
XT

Unread post07 Feb 2018, 01:35

User avatar
X
FXT
XT
 
Posts: 245
Joined: 31 Dec 2017, 18:29
Location: North Carolina
Main keyboard: F107/F122/XT/3278
Favorite switch: Buckling springs
DT Pro Member: 0204
 
The F is the best for daily use. The beamspring is the keyboard you pull out for one hour on Sunday evening, to write your journal.
DustGod
User avatar
Yet another IBM snob

Unread post07 Feb 2018, 10:41

User avatar
X
DustGod
Yet another IBM snob
 
Posts: 200
Joined: 14 Mar 2017, 08:08
Location: Italy
Main keyboard: IBM Model F 6110344 "Battleship"
Main mouse: Unbranded vertical mouse
Favorite switch: Beam Spring | Buckling Spring
DT Pro Member: 0196
 
DustGod wrote:The F is the best for daily use. The beamspring is the keyboard you pull out for one hour on Sunday evening, to write your journal.


i can't say i recall ever typing on a model F.. i do recall typing on big RS/6000 IBM servers and other models that had ibm keyboard on the don't recall if they were the beamspring models everyone is raving about ...

my first thought is ,are these type of switches ever coming back ??
i think were better of improving "Hall effect" switches....
There's lots of room for improvement there with lots of potential..
TuxKey
User avatar
LLAP

Unread post07 Feb 2018, 11:08

User avatar
X
TuxKey
LLAP
 
Posts: 436
Joined: 04 Jun 2014, 19:59
Location: Netherlands
Main keyboard: Leopold FC660C, Leopold FC660M mx-clears
Main mouse: Apple Magic Trackpad, ducky Secret (PBT mouse)
Favorite switch: Cherry MX-clear, Topre 45gr/55gr
DT Pro Member: 0137
 
DustGod.jpg


Indeed :lol:
kbdfr
User avatar
The Tiproman

Unread post07 Feb 2018, 11:10

User avatar
X
kbdfr
The Tiproman
 
Posts: 4926
Joined: 24 Mar 2011, 13:06
Location: Berlin, Germany
Main keyboard: Tipro MID-QM-128A + two Tipro matrix modules
Main mouse: Contour Rollermouse Pro
Favorite switch: Cherry black
DT Pro Member: 0010
 
kbdfr wrote:Indeed :lol:

Yup, I'm one of those :lol:
DustGod
User avatar
Yet another IBM snob

Unread post07 Feb 2018, 11:20

User avatar
X
DustGod
Yet another IBM snob
 
Posts: 200
Joined: 14 Mar 2017, 08:08
Location: Italy
Main keyboard: IBM Model F 6110344 "Battleship"
Main mouse: Unbranded vertical mouse
Favorite switch: Beam Spring | Buckling Spring
DT Pro Member: 0196
 
DustGod wrote:The F is the best for daily use. The beamspring is the keyboard you pull out for one hour on Sunday evening, to write your journal or screenplay.

ftfy
:D
just_add_coffee
User avatar

Unread post07 Feb 2018, 14:59

User avatar
X
just_add_coffee
 
Posts: 412
Joined: 03 Feb 2017, 14:25
Location: United States
Main keyboard: Model F AT, Batwing Ergodox
Main mouse: Microsoft Trackball Explorer 1.0
Favorite switch: Buckling Spring
DT Pro Member: -
 
Yep, my F122 is the perfect daily driver. Magnificent switches, and I never knew I needed an extra bank of customizable switches to my left until I got this thing. Since Ellipse is bringing back the capacitive buckling spring switch, this may well be the future.
digital_matthew
User avatar

Unread post07 Feb 2018, 15:32

User avatar
X
digital_matthew
 
Posts: 300
Joined: 29 Nov 2017, 17:08
Location: United States
Main keyboard: IBM Model F122
Main mouse: It's a Secret.
Favorite switch: Capacative Buckling Spring
DT Pro Member: -
 
 
Solenoid: ON!
In the end, keyboard switches are still just electrical switches which can be used as a momentary switch even outside of keyboards. And I think in that regard, they will never truly go away. On the other hand, Asian manufacturers of switches and components already had many of the frameworks necessary to start producing new kinds of switches (specifically keyboards in this case) and so they can undercut Cherry by a large margin. I have found switches for as low as $0.04/piece and that's not even bulk pricing. Take off an additional $.01-.02 and you are looking at a full 104-key board for as little as $2-3. I have bought an entire mechanical keyboard direct from China for $15 with Outemu switches.

Here is an example of how cheap switches can be: https://item.taobao.com/item.htm?spm=a2...=12#detail

Due to all of the unknown manufacturers that have popped up in the last few years, I've stopped trying to collect keyboard switches (I have somewhere around 150 unique in my pile if I remember correctly). It's not worth my time trying to keep up with it anymore.

To the question of which is best? That is obviously any of the Micro Switch SD series.
Blaise170
User avatar
ALPS キーボード

Unread post07 Feb 2018, 15:51

User avatar
X
Blaise170
ALPS キーボード
 
Posts: 2130
Joined: 30 Oct 2014, 22:18
Location: Boston, MA
Main keyboard: Varmilo VA87MR
Main mouse: Logitech G502
Favorite switch: Alps SKCM Blue
DT Pro Member: 0129
 
green-squid wrote:I see. I wish I had money for those good clicky switches. They must be so good, but I never find them at the flea market. :( You find them every month! Lucky.

In almost 2 years of recycler hauling, I only found a single Model F!
Wodan
User avatar
ISO Advocate

Unread post07 Feb 2018, 18:04

User avatar
X
Wodan
ISO Advocate
 
Posts: 3204
Joined: 23 Nov 2015, 20:43
Location: ISO-DE
Main keyboard: Intense Rotation!!!
Main mouse: Logitech G903
Favorite switch: ALL OF THEM
DT Pro Member: -
 
fohat wrote:I would hate to be in a public place with everyone speaking out loud whatever they wanted to put into their computers.

Wodan wrote:Voice control is a neat feature for certain purposes but I don't want to work in an office where people use voice to dictate their emails ...

Cattus_D wrote:I don't think the near-future is voice, because many of us now work in open-plan offices or, at the very least, have to share our offices with a few other people. Nobody'd be able to focus if they'd have to listen to their colleagues all day, and the computer would likely start picking up some of the background noise as well.

Sigh. :roll:

For starters, background noise doesn't matter at all with a laryngophone.

A throat microphone, also laryngophone, is a type of contact microphone that absorbs vibrations directly from the wearer's throat by way of single or dual sensors worn against the neck. The sensors, called transducers, can pick up speech even in extremely noisy or windy environments such as on a motorcycle, or in a nightclub. (…) Advanced laryngophones are able to pick up whispers, and therefore perform well in environments where communicating with others at a distance in silence is required, such as during covert military operations.

Furthermore, you don't even need a microphone for speech recognition, technology for subvocal recognition is moving forward and it's not the only option for silent speech recognition either.

A set of electrodes are attached to the skin of the throat and, without opening the mouth or uttering a sound, the words are recognized by a computer.
davkol

Unread post11 Feb 2018, 14:40

X
davkol
 
Posts: 1626
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 15:18
Location: CZ
Main keyboard: ErgoDox (home), TM2030 (office), Phantom|7bit
Main mouse: Roccat [Kova|Kone] Pure; trackballs
Favorite switch: #vintage ghost Cherry MX Black (+ thick POM caps)
DT Pro Member: -
 
There are people here that can type faster than they can speak.
Findecanor

Unread post11 Feb 2018, 17:47

X
Findecanor
 
Posts: 2966
Joined: 01 Mar 2011, 20:43
Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Main keyboard: Changes from day to day
Main mouse: Wowpen Joy (modified)
Favorite switch: I have yet to find it...
DT Pro Member: 0011
 
 
Fuck you Google for ruining YouTube!
Findecanor wrote:There are people here that can type faster than they can speak.

I wonder if I can talk at over 120WPM
FXT
User avatar
XT

Unread post11 Feb 2018, 17:56

User avatar
X
FXT
XT
 
Posts: 245
Joined: 31 Dec 2017, 18:29
Location: North Carolina
Main keyboard: F107/F122/XT/3278
Favorite switch: Buckling springs
DT Pro Member: 0204
 
Findecanor wrote:There are people here that can type faster than they can speak.

Normal speaking rates are 100-180 wpm depending on person and circumstances. There certainly are people (a small minority), who can type faster… for how long though? and with how complex output? (OTOH, there are much faster speakers too, but there's the issue of speech recognition keeping up.) BTW stenography is used for a reason.

And before someone pops up with coding, there are people coding by voice already—it's quite interesting.
davkol

Unread post11 Feb 2018, 19:56

X
davkol
 
Posts: 1626
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 15:18
Location: CZ
Main keyboard: ErgoDox (home), TM2030 (office), Phantom|7bit
Main mouse: Roccat [Kova|Kone] Pure; trackballs
Favorite switch: #vintage ghost Cherry MX Black (+ thick POM caps)
DT Pro Member: -
 
Wodan wrote:If you want clicks, get a Model F ... they're the real thing.

FXT wrote:You owe it to your fingers to try a Model F.

I agree. I was a Model M supersnob until I rediscovered the Model F. I say "rediscovered" because I must have used one in the early days of the PC but I forgot all about it until I got my F122 just recently. And then it was like "wow!!"
ClickMe

Unread post13 Feb 2018, 03:30

X
ClickMe
 
Posts: 25
Joined: 18 Jan 2018, 03:02
Location: United States
Main keyboard: Model F122
Main mouse: M510
Favorite switch: Buckling Spring
DT Pro Member: -
 
ClickMe wrote:
Wodan wrote:If you want clicks, get a Model F ... they're the real thing.

FXT wrote:You owe it to your fingers to try a Model F.

I agree. I was a Model M supersnob until I rediscovered the Model F. I say "rediscovered" because I must have used one in the early days of the PC but I forgot all about it until I got my F122 just recently. And then it was like "wow!!"

I would love to rediscover it if I found one for $30-40 anywhere!!! :(
green-squid
User avatar

Unread post13 Feb 2018, 06:34

User avatar
X
green-squid
 
Posts: 1145
Joined: 07 Oct 2017, 11:19
Location: Hungary
Main keyboard: Lexmark Dell Model M
Main mouse: Lenovo Scrollpoint optical
Favorite switch: Buckling Spring
DT Pro Member: -
 
ClickMe wrote:
Wodan wrote:If you want clicks, get a Model F ... they're the real thing.

FXT wrote:You owe it to your fingers to try a Model F.

I agree. I was a Model M supersnob until I rediscovered the Model F. I say "rediscovered" because I must have used one in the early days of the PC but I forgot all about it until I got my F122 just recently. And then it was like "wow!!"

Agreed. I used to have 2 full-size Ms and an SSK. Got rid of them shortly after getting my F XT. I just can't go back.
FXT
User avatar
XT

Unread post13 Feb 2018, 09:17

User avatar
X
FXT
XT
 
Posts: 245
Joined: 31 Dec 2017, 18:29
Location: North Carolina
Main keyboard: F107/F122/XT/3278
Favorite switch: Buckling springs
DT Pro Member: 0204
 
I'd probably use my F if the protocol converter and KVM would play nice with each other, but alas...
vometia
User avatar
irritant

Unread post13 Feb 2018, 13:50

User avatar
X
vometia
irritant
 
Posts: 234
Joined: 05 Apr 2013, 15:54
Location: Somewhere in England
Main keyboard: Unicomp SSK & Filco M2 with novelty keys
Main mouse: Roccat Malarky
Favorite switch: Avocent Thingy
DT Pro Member: 0184
 
Of course it's still a guess, but taking into account that a company like Apple hasn't been able to create a speech recognition system that works well enough to operate a smartphone, I don't think we'll see speech recognition take the keyboard's place when it comes to text input any time soon. Add to that the difficulty of adapting a speech recognition system to another language, including various dialects etc... (example: it took years before Siri was able to understand a bit of Danish).

Also, many people like the idea of privacy these days. It would be very hard to preserve, since other machines than the computer might also listen in on your conversation.

I have not worked with speech recognition myself (but I am working on finishing a PhD in audio signal processing...). Howver, at conferences I've been to so far, I haven't seen any convincing breakthroughs. Most companies seem to rely on DNNs for speech recognition, but even such methods are not yet fully understood, and it's not always easy to understand what caused a specific output of a DNN.

There are probably other factors too (e.g., the unwillingness of most people to accept radically new ideas). I'm not retiring my Topre boards anytime soon (I wonder how much fun it would be to play TypeRacer using Siri - maybe something to try) :)
Last edited by the_marsbar on 15 Feb 2018, 20:09, edited 1 time in total.
the_marsbar

Unread post15 Feb 2018, 19:09

X
the_marsbar
 
Posts: 153
Joined: 19 Feb 2016, 18:28
Location: Denmark
Main keyboard: HHKB Pro 2 Type-S
Main mouse: Apple Magic Trackpad 2
Favorite switch: Topre
DT Pro Member: -
 
vometia wrote:I'd probably use my F if the protocol converter and KVM would play nice with each other, but alas...

I would also use my F... if I had one!
green-squid
User avatar

Unread post15 Feb 2018, 19:48

User avatar
X
green-squid
 
Posts: 1145
Joined: 07 Oct 2017, 11:19
Location: Hungary
Main keyboard: Lexmark Dell Model M
Main mouse: Lenovo Scrollpoint optical
Favorite switch: Buckling Spring
DT Pro Member: -
 
Which is best? The one that works best for you :)
JP!
User avatar

Unread post15 Feb 2018, 21:45

User avatar
X
JP!
 
Posts: 1008
Joined: 01 May 2017, 03:49
Location: United States
Main keyboard: Currently a Model M
Main mouse: Steel Series Sensei
Favorite switch: Beam Spring
DT Pro Member: 0194
 
the_marsbar wrote:Also, many people like the idea of privacy these days.

That's a very apt wording.

People like the idea of privacy on paper, but very few pursue it.
the_marsbar wrote:It would be very hard to preserve, since other machines than the computer might also listen in on your conversation.

That doesn't stop people from using [smart]phones, social media and proprietary services,… or ignoring encryption, not to mention vulnerability to side-channel attacks.

Also relevant: Marc Goodman, Future Crimes.
davkol

Unread post15 Feb 2018, 22:08

X
davkol
 
Posts: 1626
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 15:18
Location: CZ
Main keyboard: ErgoDox (home), TM2030 (office), Phantom|7bit
Main mouse: Roccat [Kova|Kone] Pure; trackballs
Favorite switch: #vintage ghost Cherry MX Black (+ thick POM caps)
DT Pro Member: -
 
Previous

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Denis_HR, vvp and 56 guests