[Photos] A Cherry switches collector from China【一位来自中国的樱桃轴体收藏爱好者】

Hello everyone!I'm AFan from China.I am a ‘Cherry switches’ collecting enthusiast.I collected a lot of ‘Cherry Switches’.I would like to introduce to you one by one.And I also learned in the DT forum of other Cherry Switches information,Including a lot of switches that I did not have.I hope to get them to enrich my collection.I'm so sorry that my camera technology is not very good,Each photo belongs to me marked with a watermark,Above my WeChat account,I'm sorry I do not know what kind of online chat software you are using.If you have a switch that I do not have,I hope you get in touch with me,That would be very grateful!
大家好!我是来自中国的阿梵。我是一位“樱桃轴体”收集爱好者。我收集了很多不同的“Cherry轴体”。我想一一介绍给大家,并且我在DT论坛里了解到了很多其它樱桃信息,包括一些我所没有的轴体开关,我很希望我能够得到它们来充实我的收藏。很抱歉我的拍照技术并不是很好,每张照片都被打上了属于我的水印,上面有我的微信账号,很抱歉我并不知道你们所使用的国外的在线聊天软件,如果你有我所没有的樱桃轴体,我很希望你能和我取得联系,那将会非常感激!
IMG_5344(20161225-194035).jpg
All of mine

My English is not very good,So you basically rely on the exchange of Google translation,There may be ambiguity somewhere,I will try to avoid this situation.I can not finish it all at once because of time,So I will update it slowly.
我的英文能力并不是很好,所以和你们交流基本依赖于谷歌翻译,某些地方可能会出现歧义,我会尽量避免这种情况的发生,由于时间原因我无法一次性写完它,所以我会慢慢更新这篇帖子
IMG_5421.PNG
IMG_5422.PNG
IMG_5423.PNG
IMG_5424.PNG
IMG_5425.PNG
IMG_5426.PNG


First of all to share a very strange switch,It comes from another collector,regrettably,I do not know its origin,The forum did not find the relevant information,It is a linear switch,I temporarily call it ‘Cherry MX Linear Notch Clear’,Because its plunger side looks like Chinese characters‘凹’,It is worth mentioning that in China we call the Cherry MX Clear is ‘MX white’ , we call the Cherry MX White is ‘MX Milk ’Its special plunger makes me want to know its source.Please tell me if you know the source of it,Thanks a lot!
首先为大家分享一个非常奇特的轴体开关,它来自于另一位轴体收藏爱好者,遗憾的是,我并不知道它的出处来源,在论坛里也没有找到相关资料,它是一个线性轴体,我暂时性地叫它“樱桃MX线性凹口白轴”,因为它的轴心侧面看起来很像汉字“凹”,值得一提的是,在中国我们管MX Clear叫做白轴,把MX White 叫做奶轴,它特殊的轴心使得我很想知道它的来源出处,如果你们知道请告诉我,多谢了!
IMG_5160.JPG
IMG_5161.JPG
IMG_5163.JPG
IMG_5164.JPG


Because I play games(LOL) all night last night,So this post is temporarily only go so far,I feel very sorry,When I woke up I will continue to update
由于我昨晚通宵玩游戏(LOL哈哈)所以这篇帖子只能写到这了,我感到很抱歉,当我睡醒时我会继续更新
UncleFan

Unread post02 Jan 2017, 23:55

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
Holy crap, that's a lot of Cherry switches, general Oo . Welcome to DT, your collection is very impressive, there's some really rare ones among them too =o .
Chyros
User avatar

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 00:05

User avatar
X
Chyros
 
Posts: 3170
Joined: 28 Feb 2015, 22:04
Location: The Netherlands
Main keyboard: whatever I'm reviewing next :p
Main mouse: a cheap Logitech
Favorite switch: Alps SKCM Blue
Club member: 0152
 
 
Very impressive collection!

Are you still missing any switches?

This Cherry MX Linear Notch Clear, will it hold Alps mounts keycaps?
Wodan
User avatar
ISO Advocate

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 05:55

User avatar
X
Wodan
ISO Advocate
 
Posts: 2682
Joined: 23 Nov 2015, 20:43
Location: ISO-DE
Main keyboard: Random
Main mouse: Logitech G502
Favorite switch: ALL OF THEM
Club member: 0143
 
Chyros wrote:Holy crap, that's a lot of Cherry switches, general Oo . Welcome to DT, your collection is very impressive, there's some really rare ones among them too =o .

Thank you very much for your affirmation!非常感谢您对我的肯定!
UncleFan

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 06:11

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
Wodan wrote:Very impressive collection!

Are you still missing any switches?

This Cherry MX Linear Notch Clear, will it hold Alps mounts keycaps?

I still lack a lot of Cherry switches ,such as Hirose Cherry MX Pale Yellow,Hirose Cherry MX Grey Green,and Cheery MX LOCK White ,etc.As well as many early switches in the M series.I'm sorry I didn't get the keycaps that couled be adapt it.But I guess it can't.Its notch made it need a special keycap.
目前我仍然缺少很多樱桃轴体开关,诸如广濑灰黄轴,广濑灰绿轴和开关白轴等等,以及许多M系列的早期轴体我都没有。很抱歉我没有得到它所适配的键帽,但据我推测它不能使用,它的凹口使得它需要一个特殊的键帽。
UncleFan

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 06:44

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
If you are using WeChat,And have the Cherry switches what I haven’t.I hope you can get in touch with me.Perhaps I can learn to use foreign chat software what you are using.My WeChat account is QQ1171873935 or 1171873935.If you can help me, it will be indebted forever!
如果你有使用微信,并且拥有我所没有的樱桃轴体,我很希望你能与我取得联系,或者我可以去学习使用你所使用的国外的聊天软件。我的微信账号是QQ1171873935或者1171873935,如果你能帮助到我,那将感激不尽!
UncleFan

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 07:03

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
Hi,

please have a look at our wiki and we can add your data together, welcome to DT!

Cheers

wiki/Main_Page
seebart
User avatar
Offtopicthority Instigator

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 07:46

User avatar
X
seebart
Offtopicthority Instigator
 
Posts: 9160
Joined: 22 Nov 2013, 20:20
Location: Germany
Main keyboard: Rotation
Main mouse: Roccat Kova+
Favorite switch: Beam Spring
Club member: 0061
 
 
seebart wrote:Hi,

please have a look at our wiki and we can add your data together, welcome to DT!

Cheers

wiki/Main_Page

Thanks!I'm sorry I can't use DT skillfully.I'm trying to get familiar with it.
UncleFan

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 07:57

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
UncleFan wrote:
seebart wrote:Hi,

please have a look at our wiki and we can add your data together, welcome to DT!

Cheers

wiki/Main_Page

Thanks!I'm sorry I can't use DT skillfully.I'm trying to get familiar with it.

Sure no problem, don't worry about the wiki for now, you have all the inforamtion collected quite professionally and we can add it bit by bit later. You have interesting information on what we call the Cherry gold crosspoint switch. I have enver seen what you temporarily call the "Cherry MX Linear Notch Clear". Very nice, thanks for sharing.
seebart
User avatar
Offtopicthority Instigator

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 08:09

User avatar
X
seebart
Offtopicthority Instigator
 
Posts: 9160
Joined: 22 Nov 2013, 20:20
Location: Germany
Main keyboard: Rotation
Main mouse: Roccat Kova+
Favorite switch: Beam Spring
Club member: 0061
 
For yellow, see Aristotle Yellow.

According to … I don't recall his forum name, only his real name — Cherry have confirmed that they really did make a yellow switch, and he showed me a photo of just the slider. He's got more photos (that I've not seen), but since that point, he's vanished without a trace and Cherry suddenly lost all interest. The yellow switches I have are either 100% fake, or real/fake hybrids of some kind. They are definitely not real, but they may use some real parts.

No decent (macro) shots exist of the other unusual Cherry MX switches (odd shades of blue, Alps mount etc) so I can't comment on how likely they are to be real. For example, is the Cherry logo correct or not, and are the metal parts inside an exact match for Cherry? Is the writing and illustration on the base the correct typeface and style?

The Cherry logo on that notch switch is a match for the fake logo on Aristotle Yellow and I have a feeling it's not genuine. Notice how instead of separate cherries, it's just one solid, flat shape, as shown on the right here:

Image
Daniel Beardsmore
User avatar

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 08:33

User avatar
X
Daniel Beardsmore
 
Posts: 4530
Joined: 17 Aug 2011, 18:23
Location: Hertfordshire, England
Main keyboard: Filco Majestouch 1 (home)/Poker II backlit (work)
Main mouse: MS IMO 1.1
Favorite switch: Probably not whatever I wrote here
Club member: -
 
Daniel Beardsmore wrote:For yellow, see Aristotle Yellow.

According to … I don't recall his forum name, only his real name — Cherry have confirmed that they really did make a yellow switch, and he showed me a photo of just the slider. He's got more photos (that I've not seen), but since that point, he's vanished without a trace and Cherry suddenly lost all interest. The yellow switches I have are either 100% fake, or real/fake hybrids of some kind. They are definitely not real, but they may use some real parts.

No decent (macro) shots exist of the other unusual Cherry MX switches (odd shades of blue, Alps mount etc) so I can't comment on how likely they are to be real. For example, is the Cherry logo correct or not, and are the metal parts inside an exact match for Cherry? Is the writing and illustration on the base the correct typeface and style?

The Cherry logo on that notch switch is a match for the fake logo on Aristotle Yellow and I have a feeling it's not genuine. Notice how instead of separate cherries, it's just one solid, flat shape, as shown on the right here:

Image

Thank you very much able to put such valuable advice,In fact,LOGO this problem also troubled me for a long time.Cherry logo has undergone many generations of change,So I have many versions of cherry switch LOGO.I have suspected this switch may be counterfeit products,But I also found other fuzzy LOGO switch,And they are very early MX switch,Such as the earlier version of the Cherry MX Blue(color to be deeper),Cherry MX-M8 Adapter Black,etc.(Pictures may not be clear,But the same kind of fuzzy LOGO)Whether there is mold production is not perfect situation?Also on Cherry MX Yellow,I have read the Cherry Germany official information,It is pointed out that counterfeit products,And my Cherry MX Yellow on the LOGO looks and you are also different.So I would like to know the exact information of Cherry MX Yellow and notch switch,Thanks again for your comments can be made!
非常感谢您能提出如此宝贵的意见,事实上,LOGO这个问题也困扰了我很久。Cherrylogo经过了很多代的变化,所以我的所有樱桃轴体LOGO里有很多版本。我也曾怀疑过这款轴体可能是仿冒产品,但是我还发现了其它LOGO模糊不清的轴体,并且它们都是很早期的MX轴体,比如老青轴(比现在的青轴颜色要深),加长黑轴等(照片可能不太清晰,但实物logo与这个一样模糊)是否存在当时模具生产并不完善的情况?另外关于黄轴,我已经阅读过了Cherry德国官网的原文,指出它是仿冒产品,而且我的黄轴在LOGO上看起来与您所给出两款也有区别。所以我很想知道黄轴和凹口白轴的来历,再次感谢您的意见!
IMG_5216.JPG
IMG_5233.JPG
UncleFan

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 13:07

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
Hirose Cherry MX Linear Clear.Interesting switch!including it, I found a lot of Hirose production of the switch has a smaller a plunger than the ordinary switch, and all of the known Hirose produced switch is linear, This may be limited by the factory's single production tooling
日本广濑生产的线性白轴,很有意思的轴体开关,包括它在内,我发现很多广濑生产的轴体开关都拥有比普通轴更小的轴心,而且已知的广濑所生产的都是线性轴体,这可能是工厂单一的生产模具所限制的
image.jpg
Hirose Cherry MX Linear Clear
image.jpg
Hirose Cherry MX Linear Clear
UncleFan

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 15:34

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
A specialist in Cherry switches... Welcome UncleFan! 欢迎/歡迎!

I'm just a beginner myself getting start to understand more the history and mechanisms of mechanical keyboards.
It seems to me that your English is totally fine regarding your communication so far here - east Asians from east Asia are perhaps too modest about their English language level, e.g. also for Hasu, a respected member in GH/DT.

Please have fun collaborating with other experts in DT to unravel the many mysteries in the history of key switches. And of course, get a more complete collection of key switches for your enjoyment along the journey. :D
Menuhin

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 17:57

X
Menuhin
 
Posts: 607
Joined: 24 Jan 2016, 01:05
Location: Berlin, Germany
Main keyboard: HHKB Pro 2 black blank
Main mouse: How to make scroll ring of Expert Mouse smoother?
Favorite switch: Gateron black
 
UncleFan wrote:I found a lot of Hirose production of the switch has a smaller a plunger than the ordinary switch, and all of the known Hirose produced switch is linear, This may be limited by the factory's single production tooling

The keystem dimensions (the size of the cross-shape part that the keycap fits onto) is indeed smaller in Hirose switches. This is true for both Hirose-made M8 switches and Hirose-made MX switches. I contacted Hirose to ask for information on their switches; it seems that they have no information about their keyboard switches. Hirose had their own keycap mount, and nobody knows why. It may have been designed to match another brand of switch.
UncleFan wrote:Thank you very much able to put such valuable advice,In fact,LOGO this problem also troubled me for a long time.Cherry logo has undergone many generations of change,So I have many versions of cherry switch LOGO.I have suspected this switch may be counterfeit products,But I also found other fuzzy LOGO switch,And they are very early MX switch,Such as the earlier version of the Cherry MX Blue(color to be deeper),Cherry MX-M8 Adapter Black,etc.

Here is the problem: people in China and Taiwan collect unusual switches and never know where they came from! Even in Europe/North America, we have collectors who obtain switches and don't know/don't disclose their origin. I have started making a point of noting on the wiki what the origin is of any switch I've photographed, and I should really go through all existing pages and update them accordingly. (I have a precise record of where every one of my switches came from, although I may not know where the seller found it!)

I succeeded in persuading AliExpress seller harry ke to obtain photos of the keyboard with the Aristotle Yellow switches in. From these pictures, it appears to be a Chicony KB-5191, and it is from 1992. KB-5191 has been found with:

  • Mitsumi miniature mechanical (yellow and green)
  • Futaba clicky switch[3]
  • Aristotle Cherry MX clone (the common white ones)
  • Cherry MX Blue
  • Cherry MX Pale Blue
  • Aristotle Yellow

I only know that Chicony told me that they bought switches from Aristotle. Nobody knows what an Aristotle switch looks like. Two confirmed Cherry MX clone types have been found in Chicony keyboards, both from Taiwan white and black shaft. The type we call "Aristotle Cherry MX clone" is alps.tw type TWB 6. A second type appears in Chicony keyboards, but from the photos I've seem I'm not sure which — one of the Type 2 variants. I am guessing that all of Taiwan white and black shaft is Aristotle.

Since "Aristotle Yellow" is rather odd, I would say:

  • Aristotle Cherry MX clone: definitely a clone
  • Aristotle Yellow: definitely a clone (despite the Cherry branding)
  • Cherry MX Pale Blue: very likely to be clone

To be SURE that any Cherry MX variant (Alps mount, notch mount etc) is GENUINE Cherry, then one of the following must be true:

  • It appears in a Cherry keyboard
  • The PCB is marked "CHERRY"

The disgraced IvanIvanovich made a number of claims about old Cherry switches that are all unproven. He consistently failed to provide his sources of information, so I cannot determine if he was right or wrong.

Asian collectors usually have no idea where they found their switches, so we don't know what keyboards they came in, and how reputable the brand was on that keyboard.

What we need to do, to solve this mystery, is get reliable examples of not just the switches, but the whole keyboard, and put detailed photos of every such keyboard on the wiki. For example, IvanIvanovich claimed that early MX switches were all clear, and snuci has documented (on the wiki) a Cherry MX Black keyboard from 1984: Cherry KXN3-8451. This is the sort of data we need: photographed, dated examples showing the keyboard, and the switch, including the internal parts of the switch. With this data, we can start to build a clear picture.
Daniel Beardsmore
User avatar

Unread post03 Jan 2017, 18:37

User avatar
X
Daniel Beardsmore
 
Posts: 4530
Joined: 17 Aug 2011, 18:23
Location: Hertfordshire, England
Main keyboard: Filco Majestouch 1 (home)/Poker II backlit (work)
Main mouse: MS IMO 1.1
Favorite switch: Probably not whatever I wrote here
Club member: -
 
OK, here's something — what is this patent for?

https://www.google.com/patents/US4339643

It seems to be a variant of Cherry M9, but nothing I've ever seen before. It seems to be tactile, but I don't know what the second spring is for. When I get chance I need to read through it. I only have one type of M9 switch, which is SPST linear.
Daniel Beardsmore
User avatar

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 00:53

User avatar
X
Daniel Beardsmore
 
Posts: 4530
Joined: 17 Aug 2011, 18:23
Location: Hertfordshire, England
Main keyboard: Filco Majestouch 1 (home)/Poker II backlit (work)
Main mouse: MS IMO 1.1
Favorite switch: Probably not whatever I wrote here
Club member: -
 
Daniel Beardsmore wrote:OK, here's something — what is this patent for?

https://www.google.com/patents/US4339643

It seems to be a variant of Cherry M9, but nothing I've ever seen before. It seems to be tactile, but I don't know what the second spring is for. When I get chance I need to read through it. I only have one type of M9 switch, which is SPST linear.

This looks like a covered M8 with an earlier style slot key stem in a double pole configuration. The 1982 patent puts it really close to the move to low profile switches and the slotted key stem would have been too tall. They must have switched over to the cruciform key stem for stability and then removed the cover altogether to make the profile even slimmer. Maybe none of these were ever produced in production.
snuci
User avatar
Vintage computer guy

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 04:00

User avatar
X
snuci
Vintage computer guy
 
Posts: 893
Joined: 23 Sep 2015, 13:20
Location: Ontario, Canada
Club member: 0131
 
歡迎歡迎,想不到還有個我不知道的國內玩家在收集老櫻桃, 有5個左右我未見過的軸體, 尤其是M5黃軸T mount(這看起來不像黃吧? 是不是軸的ABS發黃了??)和凹軸, 我也想買一款一個收集研究, 我一會加你qq詳談.
你還有些老櫻桃軸沒有, M7藍色和白色軸
Image
我有這個鍵盤, 但不打算賣, 軸已清洗拆解完畢了, 你好奇的話可以找時間拍高清圖給你看看, 有機會的話也可以一起研究!
terrycherry

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 05:25

X
terrycherry
 
Posts: 556
Joined: 13 Jul 2015, 11:38
Location: Hong Kong
Main keyboard: Model M, dodoo dome keyboard, CherryMX numberic
Main mouse: logitech M705 and 2 Logitech mouses
Favorite switch: Brother BS, Hi-tek 725 series, Buckling Spring
 
snuci wrote:This looks like a covered M8 with an earlier style slot key stem in a double pole configuration.

It's definitely an M9 shell and slider. M8/9/10?/11 all use the same contact system, but that's clearly M9.

I've never seen M9 with two helical springs though — once I read the patent through it may make more sense.

I'm hoping UncleFan has a tactile M9 switch in his collection!
Daniel Beardsmore
User avatar

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 08:21

User avatar
X
Daniel Beardsmore
 
Posts: 4530
Joined: 17 Aug 2011, 18:23
Location: Hertfordshire, England
Main keyboard: Filco Majestouch 1 (home)/Poker II backlit (work)
Main mouse: MS IMO 1.1
Favorite switch: Probably not whatever I wrote here
Club member: -
 
terrycherry wrote:Image
我有這個鍵盤

What dates do you see inside (for example, on the microchips)? I want to know when this keyboard was made, because the switches are very unusual.
Daniel Beardsmore
User avatar

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 08:25

User avatar
X
Daniel Beardsmore
 
Posts: 4530
Joined: 17 Aug 2011, 18:23
Location: Hertfordshire, England
Main keyboard: Filco Majestouch 1 (home)/Poker II backlit (work)
Main mouse: MS IMO 1.1
Favorite switch: Probably not whatever I wrote here
Club member: -
 
I made some data and high quality photos of it half years ago but the thing is when I finish the final job of Cherry M5-M7, my HDD was broken. So I can't show you the exactly photo right now.
I desoldered it completely but I"ll check it and take some photo of it tomorrow.
Here's I can show you what I found:

This is the Standard version
Image

And mine and Sandy's friend keyboard are this type
[Teleprinter][France][1981]Sagem TX20 keyboard[(Linear)Black,(Linear)Blue,(Linear)White]
http://www.zonadepruebas.com/viewtopic.php?t=1411

PS. I think this keyboard you would like to find some info too.
http://db.aconit.org/dbaconit/consulter...ection=339
terrycherry

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 09:25

X
terrycherry
 
Posts: 556
Joined: 13 Jul 2015, 11:38
Location: Hong Kong
Main keyboard: Model M, dodoo dome keyboard, CherryMX numberic
Main mouse: logitech M705 and 2 Logitech mouses
Favorite switch: Brother BS, Hi-tek 725 series, Buckling Spring
 
Menuhin wrote:A specialist in Cherry switches... Welcome UncleFan! 欢迎/歡迎!

I'm just a beginner myself getting start to understand more the history and mechanisms of mechanical keyboards.
It seems to me that your English is totally fine regarding your communication so far here - east Asians from east Asia are perhaps too modest about their English language level, e.g. also for Hasu, a respected member in GH/DT.

Please have fun collaborating with other experts in DT to unravel the many mysteries in the history of key switches. And of course, get a more complete collection of key switches for your enjoyment along the journey. :D

I'm sorry to reply to you so late,Thank you very much for your praise!
很抱歉这么迟才回复您,很感谢您的赞美
UncleFan

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 10:38

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
Very interesting. What are those symbols?
The one next to '=' is like a lightbulb, the one next to '?' looks like a military symbol.

Image
Menuhin

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 10:42

X
Menuhin
 
Posts: 607
Joined: 24 Jan 2016, 01:05
Location: Berlin, Germany
Main keyboard: HHKB Pro 2 black blank
Main mouse: How to make scroll ring of Expert Mouse smoother?
Favorite switch: Gateron black
 
欢迎同胞收藏者来DT,其实我也没来多长时间,哈哈。
Mr.Nobody
User avatar

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 10:53

User avatar
X
Mr.Nobody
 
Posts: 510
Joined: 13 Dec 2016, 10:20
Location: China
Main keyboard: IBM Model M/F
Main mouse: fuhlen
Favorite switch: Buckling Spring
 
Menuhin wrote:Very interesting. What are those symbols?
The one next to '=' is like a lightbulb, the one next to '?' looks like a military symbol.

Please ask OleVoip, he already explained what is it on other post.
terrycherry

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 11:25

X
terrycherry
 
Posts: 556
Joined: 13 Jul 2015, 11:38
Location: Hong Kong
Main keyboard: Model M, dodoo dome keyboard, CherryMX numberic
Main mouse: logitech M705 and 2 Logitech mouses
Favorite switch: Brother BS, Hi-tek 725 series, Buckling Spring
 
terrycherry wrote:
Menuhin wrote:Very interesting. What are those symbols?
The one next to '=' is like a lightbulb, the one next to '?' looks like a military symbol.

Please ask OleVoip, he already explained what is it on other post.

Got it, a knowledgeable forum member from Germany!
keyboards-f2/identify-this-keyboard-thread-t10405-150.html?hilit=OleVoip#p253288
Menuhin

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 12:33

X
Menuhin
 
Posts: 607
Joined: 24 Jan 2016, 01:05
Location: Berlin, Germany
Main keyboard: HHKB Pro 2 black blank
Main mouse: How to make scroll ring of Expert Mouse smoother?
Favorite switch: Gateron black
 
Daniel Beardsmore wrote:
UncleFan wrote:I found a lot of Hirose production of the switch has a smaller a plunger than the ordinary switch, and all of the known Hirose produced switch is linear, This may be limited by the factory's single production tooling

The keystem dimensions (the size of the cross-shape part that the keycap fits onto) is indeed smaller in Hirose switches. This is true for both Hirose-made M8 switches and Hirose-made MX switches. I contacted Hirose to ask for information on their switches; it seems that they have no information about their keyboard switches. Hirose had their own keycap mount, and nobody knows why. It may have been designed to match another brand of switch.
UncleFan wrote:Thank you very much able to put such valuable advice,In fact,LOGO this problem also troubled me for a long time.Cherry logo has undergone many generations of change,So I have many versions of cherry switch LOGO.I have suspected this switch may be counterfeit products,But I also found other fuzzy LOGO switch,And they are very early MX switch,Such as the earlier version of the Cherry MX Blue(color to be deeper),Cherry MX-M8 Adapter Black,etc.

Here is the problem: people in China and Taiwan collect unusual switches and never know where they came from! Even in Europe/North America, we have collectors who obtain switches and don't know/don't disclose their origin. I have started making a point of noting on the wiki what the origin is of any switch I've photographed, and I should really go through all existing pages and update them accordingly. (I have a precise record of where every one of my switches came from, although I may not know where the seller found it!)

I succeeded in persuading AliExpress seller harry ke to obtain photos of the keyboard with the Aristotle Yellow switches in. From these pictures, it appears to be a Chicony KB-5191, and it is from 1992. KB-5191 has been found with:

  • Mitsumi miniature mechanical (yellow and green)
  • Futaba clicky switch[3]
  • Aristotle Cherry MX clone (the common white ones)
  • Cherry MX Blue
  • Cherry MX Pale Blue
  • Aristotle Yellow

I only know that Chicony told me that they bought switches from Aristotle. Nobody knows what an Aristotle switch looks like. Two confirmed Cherry MX clone types have been found in Chicony keyboards, both from Taiwan white and black shaft. The type we call "Aristotle Cherry MX clone" is alps.tw type TWB 6. A second type appears in Chicony keyboards, but from the photos I've seem I'm not sure which — one of the Type 2 variants. I am guessing that all of Taiwan white and black shaft is Aristotle.

Since "Aristotle Yellow" is rather odd, I would say:

  • Aristotle Cherry MX clone: definitely a clone
  • Aristotle Yellow: definitely a clone (despite the Cherry branding)
  • Cherry MX Pale Blue: very likely to be clone

To be SURE that any Cherry MX variant (Alps mount, notch mount etc) is GENUINE Cherry, then one of the following must be true:

  • It appears in a Cherry keyboard
  • The PCB is marked "CHERRY"

The disgraced IvanIvanovich made a number of claims about old Cherry switches that are all unproven. He consistently failed to provide his sources of information, so I cannot determine if he was right or wrong.

Asian collectors usually have no idea where they found their switches, so we don't know what keyboards they came in, and how reputable the brand was on that keyboard.

What we need to do, to solve this mystery, is get reliable examples of not just the switches, but the whole keyboard, and put detailed photos of every such keyboard on the wiki. For example, IvanIvanovich claimed that early MX switches were all clear, and snuci has documented (on the wiki) a Cherry MX Black keyboard from 1984: Cherry KXN3-8451. This is the sort of data we need: photographed, dated examples showing the keyboard, and the switch, including the internal parts of the switch. With this data, we can start to build a clear picture.

I'm sorry to reply to you so late, the source of the switch also makes me feel very distressed.Because in China,a lot of rare Cherry switches are in used electronic products businessmen there.They fried the price very high,so they will not tell the source,otherwise it will affect their profits,which makes a lot of rare switch unknown origin.Related Cherry MX yellow,I do not know if the Cherry MX yellow in China is the same as your source.Chinese-made switch there is a ZIJIN Yellow Switch,In addition to outside the shell and Cherry produced almost the same switch.The Cherry MX Yellow is likely that it is the product of being changed appearance.
黄.jpg
黄1.jpg
About PCB board,I found a very strange switch,Board has CherryLOGO,But not on the switch.
TB2lc8QqXXXXXbDXXXXXXXXXXXX_!!1843179996.jpg
TB2zQdSqXXXXXaVXXXXXXXXXXXX_!!1843179996.jpg
And this early color darker Cherry MX BLUE,It is highly unlikely fake,Because it has a known source.There may be an early mold imperfections,So there will be fuzzy LOGO.
QQ图片20170104215409.jpg
QQ图片20170104215414.jpg
Thank you for your reply to me!
很抱歉这么迟才回复您,关于开关出处的问题我也很苦恼,因为在中国,很多稀有樱桃开关都掌握在洋垃圾贩子手里,他们把价格炒的很高,所以不会告诉别人出处,这样会影响到他们的利润,这使得很多稀有轴体大多出处不明,有关黄轴我不知道中国国内的黄轴是否和您所说的出处一样,中国国产的开关里有个紫金黄轴,除了外壳之外和Cherry生产的轴几乎一模一样,很有可能是紫金黄轴换了外壳之后的产物。关于PCB板,我发现了一个很奇怪的轴体,但是卖家告诉我这个轴体没有CherryLOGO,但是PCB板上有。另外这个早期深色的青轴是仿品的可能性极低,因为它出处可查,是一块很老的板子,也许会存在Cherry早期模具不完善的情况。感谢您对我做出的回复!
UncleFan

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 13:59

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
Daniel Beardsmore wrote:OK, here's something — what is this patent for?

https://www.google.com/patents/US4339643

It seems to be a variant of Cherry M9, but nothing I've ever seen before. It seems to be tactile, but I don't know what the second spring is for. When I get chance I need to read through it. I only have one type of M9 switch, which is SPST linear.

Unfortunately, my browser can not open this page,It would be helpful if you gave the picture.
很遗憾我的浏览器无法打开这个网页,如果您给出图片的话那真是太好了。
UncleFan

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 14:02

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
terrycherry wrote:歡迎歡迎,想不到還有個我不知道的國內玩家在收集老櫻桃, 有5個左右我未見過的軸體, 尤其是M5黃軸T mount(這看起來不像黃吧? 是不是軸的ABS發黃了??)和凹軸, 我也想買一款一個收集研究, 我一會加你qq詳談.
你還有些老櫻桃軸沒有, M7藍色和白色軸
Image
我有這個鍵盤, 但不打算賣, 軸已清洗拆解完畢了, 你好奇的話可以找時間拍高清圖給你看看, 有機會的話也可以一起研究!

很高兴能在这里遇到中国朋友,欢迎讨论
UncleFan

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 14:04

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
terrycherry wrote:I made some data and high quality photos of it half years ago but the thing is when I finish the final job of Cherry M5-M7, my HDD was broken. So I can't show you the exactly photo right now.
I desoldered it completely but I"ll check it and take some photo of it tomorrow.
Here's I can show you what I found:

This is the Standard version
Image

And mine and Sandy's friend keyboard are this type
[Teleprinter][France][1981]Sagem TX20 keyboard[(Linear)Black,(Linear)Blue,(Linear)White]
http://www.zonadepruebas.com/viewtopic.php?t=1411

PS. I think this keyboard you would like to find some info too.
http://db.aconit.org/dbaconit/consulter...ection=339

Thank you for your information,I still need a lot of time to research about Cherry early switches
感谢您提供的信息,关于早期樱桃轴体我还需要很多的时间去研究
UncleFan

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 14:06

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
Mr.Nobody wrote:欢迎同胞收藏者来DT,其实我也没来多长时间,哈哈。

很高兴能遇到中国朋友!
UncleFan

Unread post04 Jan 2017, 14:07

X
UncleFan
 
Posts: 23
Joined: 26 Dec 2016, 05:53
Location: 中国
Favorite switch: cherry
Club member: -
 
Next

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 25 guests