Page 1 of 1

Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 15:41
by jejex
Hi fellow DT members, currently trying to get this to work, to no avail. I couldn't find any answers on GH, DT etc, so I'm willing to give 5$ to anyone that can help me out. Flashed the promicro with soarer's software, soldered it to the internal wires and it isn't registering any keypresses although lock LEDs are on. R04, R05 and R06 errors pop out in hid_listed on connect, then it's silent. Pics:

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 15:50
by Muirium
The Keyboard ID and Code Set are correct for an XT keyboard, so the converter is at least talking to it. The lock lights shouldn't be jammed on, though.

Is there an XT/AT switch on the keyboard? If so, switch it into AT and try again.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 15:55
by jejex
No, there is no XT/AT switch on the keyboard. It had a DIN5 connector by default, and overall I can't find much info on the keyboard itself
Oh, and the LED on the pro micro is also on at all times, I don't know if this is supposed to be this way, it's my first time using it. Maybe I got the wiring wrong?

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 15:59
by Muirium
The LED being lit up on the Pro Micro is probably a bad sign. I think Soarer uses it as a warning indicator. I had similar issues with my IBM Model F AT on one of those. It just drew too much power for the Pro Micro to handle. Went with a Teensy instead. That handled the extra load.

The wiring is probably right—or you wouldn't see the Keyboard ID stuff at all—but always worth double checking.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 16:22
by raoulduke-esq
Red light on when plugged in is normal for QMK but if Mu says it's not normal for Soarer I'd have to defer to his judgment. Did you add 1k pull-up resistors from VCC to clock and VCC to data?

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 17:16
by jejex
I didn't, the guides I read didn't mention it

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 17:28
by raoulduke-esq
I had a lot of errors with an ADB QMK converter I was making until I added external pull-up resistors. Pro Micro is supposed to have internal pull-ups but they can seemingly be insufficient for some vintage boards.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 18:08
by jejex
Which ones did you use and how exactly did you wire it up? Sorry if this is obvious, I'm not that experienced in this topic (this is my first project). TIA

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 18:17
by zrrion
Muirium wrote:
14 May 2021, 15:50
The Keyboard ID and Code Set are correct for an XT keyboard, so the converter is at least talking to it.
Point of order here, XT isn't actually capable of receiving anything from the soarers, so the converter can't talk to an XT board, only listen to it. Soarers has no way to tell the difference between not having a keyboard connected at all and an XT keyboard so it will default to XT if it doesn't get a response when it tries.

So unfortunately the converter being in XT mode doesn't mean it can see the board, and for this particular board the lock lights are handled on the keyboard itself and not by the converter so those being on really only means that it has power. Try the suggested pull up resistors and that will hopefully get it working.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 18:28
by Muirium
I know Soarer’s fairly well, but on Teensy, not Pro Micro. I blew my only Pro Micro up with that AT I mentioned earlier. Never bought one since. They’re too much trouble.

On a Teensy: the LED should definitely go out after successful connection. If it’s constantly lit, you’re in trouble. Usually something bad is happening with your wiring.



Getting nerdy now. OP please ignore!

@ Zrrion: Doesn’t Soarer’s converter wait to hear from the keyboard, recognising XT protocol, before outputting that text? It’d be remarkably dumb if it did it for a null connection.

Although you’re right that XT is strictly unidirectional, Soarer’s can still *listen* to it, before reporting the blank 00 ID.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 18:32
by jejex
What if the PCB is dead? I had no other way to test it, other than using a Soarer's converter, that means it can be dead and it not being the converter's fault, since no keypresses (I soldered in a couple of switches to test) or shorting pads manually output any codes to the converter itself.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 18:45
by kelvinhall05
Try swapping clock/data, can you also take good pics of both sides of the PCB?

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 18:50
by jejex
Swapped clock and data, the output was constant R06. Will take the pics in a minute

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 18:52
by jejex
My bad. reconnected the USB with clock and data still swapped, No output at all. Lock lights on, pro micro's LED on. Activating buttons still does nothing.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 19:04
by jejex
Alright. The condition of the PCB is... worrying to be honest. I got it this way, it had some bridges already done (in the pics)

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 19:16
by raoulduke-esq
I had an issue with a iiGS keyboard recently where it seemed dead when plugged in. Looked like there was some corrosion on the PCB around the connectors. Desoldered them and found that the pads were corroded/lifted. Wired some jumpers from the connectors to the next point along the traces and now all is good!
Screen Shot 2021-05-14 at 1.09.41 PM.png
Screen Shot 2021-05-14 at 1.09.41 PM.png (137.28 KiB) Viewed 2699 times
Here's an illustration of the concept. Hoping another comrade will chime in with a photo!

Any 1k ohm resistor should work. I used these https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0185FGTSS/

Someone may have a reason for not doing what I did, but I ran my resistors under the Pro Micro, inserting the legs up through the appropriate holes and connecting the wires to those. It worked in my case, but I was just experimenting. There are a lot of people with a lot more knowledge of circuits and controllers here so if they say that's a bad idea I'd listen to them!

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 19:19
by kelvinhall05
Can you try TMK?

Also I wanted pics of PCB to check if it had the MCU reset line connected to what would've been the original cable but it doesn't appear to.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 19:24
by jejex
I also have a DFRduino Uno V3 with ATmega328P-PU laying around, maybe it can handle this?
Edit: nevermind, it's not supported. Back to trying to make the pro micro work.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 20:04
by jejex
Update: Soldered pull up resistors like in the graph sent by raoulduke, no errors but still doesn't register any keypresses. I've ran out of ideas.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 20:29
by raoulduke-esq
Hmmmm... Sounds like the controller is happy now (pull-ups fixed my errors too). It's a shame about the board- looks like there was a fair amount of jiggery-pokery done on it. Beyond those jumpers I see some burns and such and it almost looks like the controller jumper is bridging two pins at the top. That might be part of the problem. Looks like seller tried to fool with it and gave up.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 20:37
by jejex
It had vintage blacks in it, so I made profit, but that's a shame I planned a cool project with it. Maybe I should try to do a handwired build inside the case?

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 20:56
by raoulduke-esq
That might be fun! I'm going to do similar with a AEK 1 that had an unsalvageable PCB. I think I'm gonna use amoeba PCBs to keep it clean.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 21:00
by zrrion
Muirium wrote:
14 May 2021, 18:28
@ Zrrion: Doesn’t Soarer’s converter wait to hear from the keyboard, recognising XT protocol, before outputting that text? It’d be remarkably dumb if it did it for a null connection.

Although you’re right that XT is strictly unidirectional, Soarer’s can still *listen* to it, before reporting the blank 00 ID.
If you plug in a soarers converter without a keyboard plugged in it will default to XT.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 21:03
by jejex
Amoeba PCBs seem like a great idea! I tried TMK too, here's what hid_listen says:

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 21:24
by jejex
I assume the PCB is dead this way. I ordered a bunch of amoeba PCBs and will use them inside the case. Thanks for all the help guys!

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 21:30
by raoulduke-esq
Be sure to share your results! I'd love to see what you do.

Re: Need help with using a soarer's converter with a MX Style KB-5150-1 model F clone

Posted: 14 May 2021, 21:45
by jejex
All I can say now, it's gonna be clicky!