Best keyboard switch 2013

User avatar
webwit
Wild Duck

22 Nov 2013, 01:54

Image

Please suggest nominees for the Best keyboard switch in 2013. You have to give a short motivation for each suggestion.

Current suggestions (this list is frequently updated):
  • Cherry MX Lock
  • Nixdorf "Soft Touch" Black
  • Clicky Univac magnetic switches
  • Honeywell Micro Switch
  • Matias Quiet switch
  • Cherry MX Black
  • Cherry MX Brown
  • IBM beam spring
  • Alps Plate Spring
  • Cherry MX Ergo Clear
  • Cherry MX Clear
  • Topre switch
  • IBM buckling spring
  • Cherry MX Green
  • Matias Click switch

User avatar
rindorbrot

22 Nov 2013, 02:36

The only non-momentary switch in the Cherry MX lineup:
Cherry MX Lock

User avatar
photekq
Cherry Picker

22 Nov 2013, 02:37

The Nixdorf "Soft Touch" Black without a doubt in my mind, as they are the perfect linear MX switch. They are perfectly smooth without lubricant, and allow a large amount of customisation like the rest of the MX line.

User avatar
Muirium
µ

22 Nov 2013, 02:46

The mad clicky Univac that HaaTa discovered this year:

User avatar
HaaTa
Master Kiibohd Hunter

22 Nov 2013, 03:44

Oh, once I get a couple of projects out of the way, I'm planning on assembling a team to reproduce the Univac magnetic switches :D

User avatar
7bit

22 Nov 2013, 09:09

Micro Switch.
Image

User avatar
Julle

22 Nov 2013, 13:45

I nominate the Matias Quiet Pro switch. It takes some serious balls to make a mechanical keyboard with anything else than Cherry switches these days.

User avatar
CeeSA

22 Nov 2013, 14:05

good point Julle - Matias Quiet Pro.

User avatar
Jmneuv

22 Nov 2013, 14:09

photekq wrote:The Nixdorf "Soft Touch" Black
Can you elaborate, please? Never heard of that switch.

User avatar
photekq
Cherry Picker

22 Nov 2013, 16:18

Jmneuv wrote:
photekq wrote:The Nixdorf "Soft Touch" Black
Can you elaborate, please? Never heard of that switch.
These babies : Image

The original Cherry clear switch top.
PERFECTLY smooth without any modding - seriously, there is absolutely no scratchiness whatsoever.
Photo from ascaii

User avatar
Muirium
µ

22 Nov 2013, 17:11

The classic vintage black. How did they go wrong!

User avatar
kbdfr
The Tiproman

22 Nov 2013, 17:13

I'd like to nominate the Cherry MX black switch.

I hold it for the best switch ever made.
Simple, reliable, smooth and steady.
It guides your fingers on their way down and gently escorts them on their way up.
The perfect touch. Exactly what a professional typist needs :mrgreen:

Edit: :lol:

User avatar
Ekaros

22 Nov 2013, 17:18

kbdfr wrote:I'd like to nominate the Cherry MX black switch.

I hold it for the best switch ever made.
Simple, reliable, smooth and steady.
It guides your fingers on their way down and gently escorts them on their way up.
The perfect touch. Exactly what a professional typist needs :mrgreen:

Edit: :lol:
Heretic, MX Brown is the correct way!

I suggest a pre-poll for picking up one MX switch... Or group them to one...

User avatar
Halvar

22 Nov 2013, 17:22

IBM beam spring. Now usable again.

User avatar
Muirium
µ

22 Nov 2013, 17:28

Quit showing off you, Mr. Beam Spring debutante!

I'll agree as soon as I have one too, of course. The one I've tried in a museum was magnificent.

User avatar
Compgeke

22 Nov 2013, 18:31

I'm a bit odd in that I actually quite like the Alps Plate Spring switch that's used in the PS/2 P70. My only complaint is the PS/2 P70 has a raised keyboard without plate mounted switches, making for a very flexible keyboard.

User avatar
Game Theory
Mr. Despair

22 Nov 2013, 20:53

Clicky Univac magnetic switches sound so nice!

mr_a500

22 Nov 2013, 21:43

That UNIVAC disturbs me... because now I have to find one.

I thought my keyboard quest was over with my beam spring, but now HaaTa has found not one, but two keyboards I must search for: the other being the ALPS magnetic reed keyboard. If there was a separate category for "Best clicky switch" and "Best linear", HaaTa could take both prizes with those two keyboards.

User avatar
Dubsgalore

22 Nov 2013, 22:32

Vintage Blacks are my favorite from experience
photekq wrote:The Nixdorf "Soft Touch" Black without a doubt in my mind, as they are the perfect linear MX switch. They are perfectly smooth without lubricant, and allow a large amount of customisation like the rest of the MX line.
How I wish i could try these..

User avatar
TheSoulhunter

23 Nov 2013, 09:12

Ergo Clears, because... it's my favorite!
Also because all these custom springs (62g, 65g, 67g...) became available -> Less sticky Ergo Clears

User avatar
Muirium
µ

23 Nov 2013, 10:57

HaaTa wrote:Oh, once I get a couple of projects out of the way, I'm planning on assembling a team to reproduce the Univac magnetic switches :D
For some reason I can't get this song out of my head.
There's going to be welding, helicopters and costumes, right? Looking forward to it!

User avatar
webwit
Wild Duck

23 Nov 2013, 14:42

Alternatively, if that doesn't work out, MacGyver will reproduce the Univac magnetic switches with nothing more than duck tape, fridge magnets, a rope, and spit.

mr_a500

23 Nov 2013, 14:44

As long as there's a helicopter, I'm in. There also has to be a red Ferrari and an estate in Hawaii... oh wait a minute - that's Magnum P. I.

User avatar
Muirium
µ

23 Nov 2013, 14:48

Note to TV execs: get back on your helicopters, take a good line of Beverley Hills high tea, and do what your 80s forefathers did! Those shows, those cuckoo, instantaneously classic shows.

User avatar
Belfong

23 Nov 2013, 15:01

I think we gotta put MX Clears. Made even more popular by Code keyboard until it was out of stock WW and everyone is still hunting for one.

Findecanor

23 Nov 2013, 17:57

Belfong wrote:I think we gotta put MX Clears.
I second this. Was going to nominate if you hadn't beaten me to it.

User avatar
Ekaros

23 Nov 2013, 18:46

Do we have time to do something different with this category?

This is horribly wide category always, any good options to narrow it down?

User avatar
Muirium
µ

23 Nov 2013, 18:50

Pitting old vs. new (let alone home made, as in several other categories) makes for a crazy vote. But that's what the first round is for, I guess. I'll be voting for the ancient novelty of Univac switches on this one (and Hall effects and beam springs if we get multiple votes) but for new stuff in other some categories. Just depends on the field.

User avatar
Ekaros

23 Nov 2013, 19:30

Cherry MX could alone have the options for sufficient poll, throw in ALPs for good measure and we have same amount of canditates than a few other categories combined...

THESE ARE NO SUGGESTIONS
Cherry MX:
Black
Blue
Brown
Clear
Green
Grey
Red
White
And lock...

ALPS:
More crazy ;D

User avatar
Muirium
µ

23 Nov 2013, 19:53

A little digging in the archive, and I present for reference:

Best keyboard switch 2011: Cherry MX Brown.
Best keyboard switch 2012: Cherry MX Ergo Clear.

Can the tyranny of MX be put to an end before Cherry wins the hat trick? Can spring bucklers and rubber cuppers put aside their differences to unite against continued dominion? Can the archaeologists settle on some bloody thing? Can 002 ever find a hat that doesn't split open at the crown? The truth, gentleman, will out!

Post Reply

Return to “Call for nominees”