Page 1 of 1

An IBM M keypad that feels like an F.

Posted: 01 Dec 2017, 03:19
by depletedvespene
This is supposed to be the M version of the IBM 4704 Model 100 keypad. It sports the gray IBM oval logo, has a plastic backside and M's flip-out feet, and even sports an SDL plug.
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, frontside.
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, frontside.
F-or-M-1_th.jpg (362.19 KiB) Viewed 5513 times
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, backside.
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, backside.
F-or-M-2_th.jpg (303.61 KiB) Viewed 5513 times
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, label (tampered with, but what the heck).
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, label (tampered with, but what the heck).
F-or-M-3_th.jpg (282.72 KiB) Viewed 5513 times
Yet... typing on it feels quite closer to typing on a Model F than on a Model M.

Why?
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, are those regular flippers or not?.
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, are those regular flippers or not?.
F-or-M-4_th.jpg (288.49 KiB) Viewed 5513 times
A quick topside look at the springs doesn't yield much, so... let's open it.
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, internal plate front view.
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, internal plate front view.
F-or-M-5_th.jpg (476.55 KiB) Viewed 5513 times
Frontside doesn't tell us much.
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, panel's backside. Oh, moderately shiny!
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, panel's backside. Oh, moderately shiny!
F-or-M-6_th.jpg (468.74 KiB) Viewed 5513 times
Is this a SHINY backplate? Like Model F units had?
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, panel's backside with a better view of the controller.
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, panel's backside with a better view of the controller.
F-or-M-7_th.jpg (532.72 KiB) Viewed 5513 times
The controller looks like an M-era model...
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, plate sandwich.
IBM Modem M 4704-Model-100-like, plate sandwich.
F-or-M-8_th.jpg (313.75 KiB) Viewed 5513 times
... the sandwiched foam, on the other hand, screams of Fness.

And with that, I stop. If I open this up, I'll surely won't be able to put it back together.

I bought this keypad as a fun toy, to use as a side pad or a sophisticated game pad of sorts; I did not expect it to bring this pleasant surprise. What a fun... hybrid? intermediate evolutionary step? keypad.

I now kinda want to procure one of the later models, manufactured by Lexmark, if only to see if typing on it would feel more like a Model M than a Model F.

Posted: 01 Dec 2017, 04:16
by arkanoid
If somebody makes a PCB for this, then it would be able to make a semi-model F.
Or if you want a bigger project, then you can try to build build an ergodox model F using two keyboards. :)
By the way, feet are different from those of regular model M as I remember.

Posted: 01 Dec 2017, 05:43
by Darkshado
Hard to tell with the flash, black flippers would point towards an F, white are a pretty surefire sign of an M.
139* part numbers are associated with model M.
The controller photos clearly show two superposed membranes; it should be possible to lift the foam slightly and see the PCB on an F as well.
Individual barrels on an M are peculiar, are there other known examples?
We did see that plastic barrel plate style F typewriter assembly not long ago, so there is some overlap in the techniques on both models.

Re: An IBM M keypad that feels like an F.

Posted: 01 Dec 2017, 08:22
by xueyao
It's definitely a Model M, I've got one and opened it up before and it's membrane is exactly like an M. If anyone could design a PCB I'll love to test turning this into a full F.

Posted: 01 Dec 2017, 12:06
by seebart
Darkshado wrote: We did see that plastic barrel plate style F typewriter assembly not long ago, so there is some overlap in the techniques on both models.
That's the interesting part, thanks for posting depletedvespene!

Posted: 01 Dec 2017, 13:54
by andrewjoy
IBM, would it really have cost that much more to keep the M like this!

You had the tooling to automatically assemble F's i have seen the vids :).

Does switching to heat melted plastic really same that much money ?

And don't forget , you can make almost all the spare parts for your existing customer who have F's on the same production line!

Posted: 02 Dec 2017, 00:24
by PlacaFromHell
Great find! Those keypads have a really distinctive feel. Maybe is not the same, but mine (that we talked about months ago)
has a strong bottom feeling like short travel switches (for example the short travel futabas), accompanied by a TAP sound. Anyway, would be interesting see it working. Do you checket his compatibility?

Posted: 02 Dec 2017, 00:30
by depletedvespene
The one in the pictures is already in active usage by my son. I haven't started using the other one (as I want to clean it a bit first), but I expect it to work just as nicely. At least the typing feel is the same.

IIRC, your unit must be Lexmark made - mine are a bit older, IBM made, and it may be that your unit does have a typing feel like the regular Model M keyboards. We need to determine it for sure. :-)

Posted: 02 Dec 2017, 03:52
by PlacaFromHell
Mine is blue label, so your board is older. I put it in front of my daily use battle cruiser and they definitely sound and feel different. What I mean is that these "planck" IBM's are a whole different world.

Posted: 02 Dec 2017, 04:17
by snuci
This looks to be similar to the "hybrid Model M/F" in the screenreader keypad here: photos-f62/ibm-model-m-os-2-screen-read ... 13488.html

Posted: 01 Jan 2018, 23:22
by PlacaFromHell
Sorry for reviving this, but I just noticed today that mine is a M/F too. You can easily notice that by the swinging of the barrels. I did not expect that of a blue label, but it's awesome anyway.

Posted: 09 Dec 2018, 11:23
by tentator
I also found one and can confirm the switches really snap nicely, much more like an f than an m.. So theory is that's because the metal plate joints?
Spoiler:
MVIMG_20181208_225225.jpg
MVIMG_20181208_225225.jpg (9.01 MiB) Viewed 5027 times
MVIMG_20181208_225419.jpg
MVIMG_20181208_225419.jpg (7.81 MiB) Viewed 5021 times
Lexmark!
MVIMG_20181208_225410.jpg
MVIMG_20181208_225410.jpg (8.57 MiB) Viewed 5027 times
Tent:wq

Posted: 10 Dec 2018, 02:06
by John Doe
Is there any f50's PCB existing? Maybe could make some mod for an M50.

Posted: 11 Dec 2018, 13:13
by depletedvespene
tentator wrote: I also found one and can confirm the switches really snap nicely, much more like an f than an m.. So theory is that's because the metal plate joints?
Yup, that's what I think.