Page 1 of 1

Anyone know of a good scissor switch keyboard besides the Logitech k740?

Posted: 28 Feb 2020, 14:17
by finacoles2
Was wondering because i currently have a gaming membrane keyboard, and i'd love to have a scissor switch keyboard that's capable for gaming. In my experience, scissor switches seem quieter than membrane. Thanks in advance.

Mod Edit: this is clearly a spam post as there was hidden links in the post. User has been banned and links removed however topic is a valid one so will leave up for now

Re: Anyone know of a good scissor switch keyboard besides the Logitech k740?

Posted: 28 Feb 2020, 14:56
by sharktastica
An example that comes to mind is the Lenovo ThinkPad Compact USB Keyboard (KU-1255). Low-travel, nice tactility, fairly quiet, and feels fast.

Also, as an FYI most (if not all) scissor-switch keyboards are membrane driven and thus subject to the same general limitations. Membranes are a type of layered circuit sensing element, and the scissors are a mechanism that stabilises small rubber domes (the smallness being the reason they're quieter) that sit on top.

Re: Anyone know of a good scissor switch keyboard besides the Logitech k740?

Posted: 03 Mar 2020, 21:26
by Spearra
The Perixx PX 1900 is a gaming scissor switch keyboard that isn't built like a wet newspaper roll unlike most scissor switch keyboards.

It's membrane matrix is optimised so the keys don't screw up in a gaming session. I use mine occasionally for a rhythm game that uses 9 keys, sometimes simultaneously if that's any indication.

Hands down one of the best scissor switch keyboards I've ever used period.

Re: Anyone know of a good scissor switch keyboard besides the Logitech k740?

Posted: 04 Mar 2020, 02:12
by HungerMechanic
Perixx told me last year that they are working on an 'office' version of that keyboard that has appropriate aesthetics. I hope that they do release something like that. I'd like a serious scissor-switch keyboard.

The Logitech K740 had a good reputation, but if you look at more recent Amazon.com reviews, it seems that it rolls over a smaller number of keys now, and other cheapening measures have been applied. Too bad, really, as I could have been happy with the better-built PerfectStroke keyboards of an earlier era.

Re: Anyone know of a good scissor switch keyboard besides the Logitech k740?

Posted: 04 Mar 2020, 20:41
by Riverman
I really liked some of Logitech's PerfectStroke keyboards before I got back into mechanicals. I had a couple of DiNovo keyboards, the Mac version and the "for Notebooks" version, which were identical full-sized keyboards. They had a great snap to the keys, and they were very quiet. I used one in my office for a few years. The corded illuminated keyboard was also a PerfectStroke keyboard with a very similar feel, but the cordless version didn't feel nearly as nice. Logitech also says that the MX Keys is a PerfectStroke keyboard. I've yet to see one in a store so I can try one out, though. My only beef with all of those is that eventually the legends on the keys wear out, and it's nearly impossible to get replacements.

Re: Anyone know of a good scissor switch keyboard besides the Logitech k740?

Posted: 04 Mar 2020, 22:17
by Findecanor
Riverman wrote: 04 Mar 2020, 20:41Logitech also says that the MX Keys is a PerfectStroke keyboard.
The Logitech Craft and MX Keys have low key travel. Not comparable to the DiNovos and K740 at all.

Re: Anyone know of a good scissor switch keyboard besides the Logitech k740?

Posted: 05 Mar 2020, 18:16
by abrahamstechnology
The best scissor keyboard I tried is from an old Dell laptop (it has METAL scissors instead of plastic, I can make a post if interested)
Likely not useful to you unless you want to use a Pentium III lol.

Re: Anyone know of a good scissor switch keyboard besides the Logitech k740?

Posted: 06 Mar 2020, 10:35
by snarfangel
abrahamstechnology wrote: 05 Mar 2020, 18:16 The best scissor keyboard I tried is from an old Dell laptop (it has METAL scissors instead of plastic, I can make a post if interested)
Likely not useful to you unless you want to use a Pentium III lol.
The one on my wife's old Dell Studio 1537 (Model PP33L) has the best feel of any laptop I've tried. It looks like the Manufacturer part/Dell part number is KR766.

It may be a Darfon (Chinese company) NSK-DC101.