What are double-action key switches good for?

Findecanor

10 Mar 2017, 01:00

There are a few rare switches that are double action, meaning that they have one actuation distance and a second actuation if you press it deeper. I see that some have been found in typewriters on Return, Space and Backspace keys...
But there is something that I have missed...

What were double-action key switches used for?

And ... what would you use them for?

User avatar
Daniel Beardsmore

10 Mar 2017, 01:24

The patent for [wiki]Olivetti snap action[/wiki] does note that the second stage can be used for key repeat (this form has not been seen, but it is illustrated in the patent).

I have one and a half double-action switches, and stage two is heavy enough to drive a family car over it. To get key repeat you'd have to put the key in question in a vice. The Alps specifications suggest something as heavy as my Mitsumi switch.

I don't think anyone's ever proven the function of the keys, which is curious as several people do have typewriters with these switches in (Mitsumi, Alps, Marquardt, but not Cherry yet so far as I know). Maybe they have — the wiki is only a fraction of the knowledge gained and lost within the forums.

User avatar
Phenix
-p

10 Mar 2017, 01:38

one can code somethink similar with QMK (do 1, 2, 3.. If tapped, do F1, F2, .. if held for X ms)

User avatar
Ratfink

10 Mar 2017, 02:24

The most common use is probably pressing harder for key repeat. At the very least, that's how the Selectric spacebar works. Honestly, I kind of like that more than the software delay we have today.

Findecanor

10 Mar 2017, 03:14

There we got confirmation of key repeat. Thanks!

User avatar
ullr

10 Mar 2017, 04:23

I think the most interesting use would be for simultaneous modifier keys. I’d like a layout with one under both Controls mapping to Shift, and two under the Alt keys mapping to Shift and Control respectively so I can have two alts, Alt Gr (via Control + Alt), and simple two‐key cords for all common key bindings in a very tight form factor. The Menu/Application key also seems to activate on upstroke in most contexts in my experience, so it’s ideal for having another key “under it”, perhaps a macro key. I think a dual FN/FN2 key would be perfect for 40% layouts, as well.

User avatar
Chyros

10 Mar 2017, 09:23

IIRC they are now using double action switches to develop analog-like keyboards for gaming.

Post Reply

Return to “Keyboards”