Poll & build log: switch measurement system

Which switch should I measure first?

Acer
1
13%
Alps SKCL Green
0
No votes
Alps SKCM Blue
0
No votes
Alps SKCM White
0
No votes
Alps SKFL Grey
1
13%
Aristotle (clicky Cherry clone)
0
No votes
Cherry Black
2
25%
Cherry Blue
0
No votes
Cherry Brown
1
13%
Cherry Clear
0
No votes
Cherry Green
0
No votes
Cherry Grey (linear)
0
No votes
Cherry Nixdorf (vintage black)
0
No votes
Cherry Red
1
13%
Cherry White
1
13%
Gateron Black
0
No votes
Gateron Blue
0
No votes
Gateron Brown
0
No votes
Gateron Clear
0
No votes
Gateron Lock
0
No votes
Gateron Red
0
No votes
Gateron Yellow
0
No votes
Green Razer
0
No votes
IBM Buckling Spring, F
0
No votes
IBM Buckling Spring, M
1
13%
NEC Blue Oval
0
No votes
SMK/Monterey Blue
0
No votes
Zealio Clear (don't recall the grams)
0
No votes
Zealio Purple (don't recall the grams)
0
No votes
 
Total votes: 8

User avatar
ohaimark
Kingpin

24 Jan 2016, 06:41

^^^^^ Please vote. ^^^^^

I received the first structural component for my switch tester today. That means it's time to start on this topic.

Build Objectives:
I) Objective press force measurements
II) Objective travel distance measurements
III) When measuring distance, .02 mm margin of error and .05 mm granularity
IV) When measuring force, .6% margin of error and 1 gf granularity

That results in 80 data points over the course of an MX Switch's advertised 4mm of travel and 160 if the upstroke is measured. I may need to rethink that if the measurements take FOREVER to do.

Build Materials:
I) Drill press conversion kit: ON THE WAY
Spoiler:
Image
II) Digital vernier calipers: ARRIVED
Spoiler:
Image
III) Mark 10 MG2 force gauge: ARRIVED
Spoiler:
Image
IV) 3-D printed MX switch holder: CREATED
Spoiler:
Image
V) Assorted hardware: will be purchased as necessary.

Notes -- Materials:
Calipers: These are nicer than I anticipated. The calipers store their position in memory when powered off and automatically power on when movement occurs, meaning I don't need to worry about shutting them down and losing my place in the measurements.

MG2 gauge: $50 for a $500 measurement unit? Yes please. 1 gf is its absolute minimum resolution, but that's fine with me considering the price point and quality.

Rough Build Plan:
I'll use a fine threaded bolt mounted on the drill press' side (across the spot that "splits" open and exposes the spring) to move the lower portion in minute increments, much like 3-D printer axes. The caliper will be attached to the opposite side to measure how far the sides have "split," representing the distance that the press force meter has traveled. I plan to mount the tester below the round bit that holds the drill, on it, or on a modified (read: hacksawed off) version of it. All things considered, a simple project.

Updates:
I'll likely post two updates: one with the build process and one with the finished product (and a fully measured force curve as proof of functionality).

User avatar
ohaimark
Kingpin

05 Feb 2016, 05:50

Update I:

My plan failed. :? The drill press stand didn't work as intended.

Instead I'll be doing a bit of carpentry. My intent is to create a "guillotine" style tester that's much more controllable.

Post Reply

Return to “Keyboards”